Important Pros And Cons Of Cedar Mulch You Need To Know

Mulching is a quintessential part of garden management, crucial for maintaining the sanctity and health of soil and plants. Among the different types of mulch, cedar mulch stands out as a popular choice for gardeners and landscapers. This article delves into the nuances of cedar mulch, exploring its pros and cons, and providing insights into its optimal use.

Closeup image of red cedar wood chips YayImages

What is Cedar Mulch?

Cedar mulch, derived from the wood of cedar trees, is a type of organic mulch used extensively in gardening and landscaping. Known for its pleasant aroma and natural color, cedar mulch is more than just an aesthetic addition; it offers a multitude of pros (and also some cons) to the soil and plants it surrounds.

Pros of Cedar Mulch

Cedar mulch is a gardener’s ally, offering a suite of advantages that cater to both the health of the soil and the aesthetic requirements of a garden. It stands out for its multifunctional capabilities, ranging from enhancing soil quality to beautifying landscape designs. Let’s delve into the best cedar mulch pros:

1. Enhancing Moisture Retention

Cedar mulch is particularly adept at retaining moisture, a crucial feature for maintaining soil hydration. This characteristic is invaluable in arid climates or during dry seasons, where water conservation is paramount. By retaining moisture, cedar mulch ensures that plants remain hydrated and reduces the frequency of watering, thus conserving water resources.

2. Regulating Soil Temperature

Cedar mulch serves as an effective insulator for soil, regulating its temperature by shielding it from the harsh extremities of weather. This layer of protection is beneficial in both hot and cold climates, protecting plant roots from extreme temperatures and fostering an environment conducive to plant growth.

3. Natural Weed Suppression

One of the most appreciated benefits of cedar mulch is its ability to suppress weed growth. The mulch forms a dense physical barrier on the soil surface, preventing the germination and spread of weed seeds. This natural form of weed control reduces the need for chemical herbicides, making it an environmentally friendly option.

4. Preservation of Soil Nutrients

As cedar mulch breaks down, it slowly releases organic nutrients back into the soil. This gradual decomposition enriches the soil over time, enhancing its fertility and structure. This process is particularly beneficial for gardens requiring a steady supply of organic matter.

5. Deterrence of Insect Infestations

The essential oils present in cedar, especially notable in varieties like western red cedar, have natural insect-repellent properties. These natural oils deter a variety of insect pests, making cedar mulch an excellent choice for gardens prone to insect infestations.

6. Visual Enhancement Purposes

Cedar mulch is aesthetically pleasing, with its natural color and texture adding visual interest to garden beds. This makes it an excellent choice for landscape designs where the visual appeal of the mulch complements the overall garden aesthetic.

7. Remarkable Durability

Cedar mulch’s longevity is superior to many other organic mulches. It decomposes at a slower rate, meaning it needs to be replaced less frequently. This durability makes it a cost-effective option for gardeners and landscapers.

8. Mitigation of Soil Erosion

In areas prone to soil erosion, such as slopes or places with loose soil, cedar mulch can be a savior. Its ability to anchor the soil in place reduces the impact of erosion caused by wind and water.

9. Aromatic Benefits

The distinct and pleasant aroma of cedar mulch not only enhances the sensory experience of a garden but also contributes positively to the garden’s environment. This fragrance can make spending time in the garden more enjoyable for many people.

A pile of wood chips in a garden ready to be used for mulch in landscapingYayImages

Cons of Cedar Mulch

While cedar mulch is lauded for its numerous pros, it’s crucial to consider its potential drawbacks and cons to ensure it aligns with specific gardening needs and environments. Understanding these limitations can help gardeners make informed choices for their landscape and plant health. Let’s delve into the cons of cedar mulch:

1. Impact on Beneficial Insect Populations

Cedar mulch’s natural insect-repellent properties, while effective against harmful pests, can inadvertently affect beneficial insect populations. Important garden allies like parasitic wasps, which play a crucial role in controlling pest populations, may be deterred. This imbalance can affect the natural ecosystem of the garden, reducing the benefits these beneficial bugs bring.

2. Alteration of Soil Acidity

Over time, the decomposition of cedar mulch can lead to an increase in soil acidity. This change in pH may not be conducive to all plant types, particularly those that thrive in neutral to alkaline soil conditions. Gardeners should consider the specific pH requirements of their plants before opting for cedar mulch.

3. Prolonged Decomposition Rate

The slow decomposition rate of cedar mulch is a double-edged sword. While it means the mulch lasts a long time and requires less frequent replacement, it also contributes organic material to the soil at a slower pace compared to other organic mulches. This slower enrichment process can delay the improvement of soil structure and fertility.

4. Rapid Color Fading

Cedar mulch is initially known for its vibrant natural color, but it tends to fade relatively quickly under environmental elements like sun and rain. This loss of color can detract from the visual appeal that cedar mulch initially provides in landscaping and garden designs.

5. Higher Cost Implications

In terms of cost, cedar mulch is generally more expensive than other types of mulch. This higher price point can be a significant consideration, especially for gardeners working with a large area or those on a budget.

6. Potent Aroma

The distinct smell of cedar mulch, though often considered one of the pros of using this type of mulch, can also be one of the cons as it can be overwhelming for some individuals. In certain cases, it may trigger allergic reactions or skin irritations, making it a less suitable choice for those with sensitivities to strong fragrances.

7. Potential for Nitrogen Depletion

As cedar mulch breaks down, it can temporarily tie up nitrogen in the soil, a phenomenon known as nitrogen depletion. This temporary reduction in available nitrogen can impact plant growth, particularly for nitrogen-hungry plants. Gardeners may need to supplement with additional nitrogen fertilizers to counteract this effect.

New Garden Wood Fence with house siding barkdust mulch concrete retaining wall along exterior sidewalkYayImages

When to Use Cedar Mulch

Selecting the right type of mulch for specific gardening needs is crucial, and cedar mulch, with its unique characteristics, is particularly well-suited for various gardening scenarios. Understanding when to use cedar mulch can help maximize its benefits while complementing the garden’s aesthetic and functional requirements. Here are some examples of when cedar mulch is the best mulch for your garden:

1. Perennial Plant Beds

Cedar mulch is an excellent choice for perennial beds. Its long-lasting nature means it doesn’t need to be replaced as often as other mulches, and it provides a visually appealing, protective layer. The mulch helps maintain consistent soil temperature and moisture levels, which are essential for the health of perennial plants.

2. Garden Pathways and Dog Walking Areas

For creating natural-looking paths and dog walks, cedar wood chips or shavings are a good option. They offer a firm yet soft surface, reducing mud and dust, and their weed control properties help maintain clear walkways. Additionally, the pleasant smell of cedar can enhance the sensory experience of strolling through the garden.

3. Surrounding Plants and Flower Bed Coverage

Cedar mulch is ideal for use around plants and in flower beds. It acts as an effective barrier against soil erosion and helps retain moisture, which is particularly beneficial during dry spells. Its insulating properties also protect plant roots from temperature extremes, fostering a conducive growth environment.

4. Hot and Arid Climatic Conditions

In areas with hot and dry climates, maintaining soil moisture is a challenge. Cedar mulch is highly effective in these conditions, as it helps to retain moisture in the soil, reducing the need for frequent watering and protecting plants from heat stress.

5. Extreme Weather Environments

Gardens situated in regions with extreme weather conditions, be it hot or cold, can benefit significantly from cedar mulch. Its insulating properties shield plant roots from temperature fluctuations, safeguarding them against frost in cold climates and excessive heat in warmer regions.

6. Enhancing Garden Aesthetics

Cedar mulch is not just about functionality; it also enhances the visual appeal of garden beds. Its natural color and texture add an elegant touch to landscaping designs, making it a popular choice for gardeners and landscapers who place a high value on the aesthetic aspect of their gardens.

mulch trail or path with plants and flowers in gardenYayImages

When Not To Use Cedar Mulch

While cedar mulch is beneficial in many scenarios, there are specific situations where its use may not be advisable. Understanding these circumstances can help gardeners avoid potential issues and select a mulch type that is more suited to their specific gardening needs.

1. Sensitivity to Fragrances

Individuals who are sensitive to strong scents or suffer from fragrance allergies should be cautious with cedar mulch. The robust and distinct aroma of cedar, while pleasant to many, can be overpowering and potentially trigger allergic reactions or exacerbate existing allergies. In such cases, opting for a less fragrant mulching option would be more suitable.

2. High-Moisture Environments

In regions that experience high levels of moisture or have predominantly wet climates, cedar mulch may not be the most appropriate choice. Its slow decomposition rate in moist conditions can lead to issues like mold or fungus growth. Additionally, in already damp environments, the water retention quality of cedar mulch could result in overly moist soil, potentially harming plant roots.

3. Gardens with Acidic Soil

Gardens with naturally acidic soil should avoid using cedar mulch, as it tends to lower the soil’s pH further. Plants that prefer neutral to alkaline soil conditions may struggle or fail to thrive if cedar mulch exacerbates the soil’s acidity. In such gardens, a mulch that has a neutral or alkaline effect on the soil would be a better choice.

4. Areas Frequented by Chickens

For gardeners who also raise chickens, it’s important to note that cedar chips or shavings might not be suitable for use in areas where chickens roam. The aromatic compounds in cedar can be harmful to chickens’ respiratory systems, posing a health risk. Therefore, a safer, non-toxic mulching alternative should be considered in these areas.

5. Annual Vegetable Gardens

Cedar mulch is typically not recommended for annual vegetable gardens, particularly for vegetables that prefer neutral or alkaline soil. The potential of cedar mulch to make the soil more acidic can adversely affect the growth and yield of these vegetables. Gardeners should opt for a mulch that maintains or improves the desired soil pH for their vegetable crops.

A gardener adding mulch wood chips to the gardenRDNE Stock Project / Pexels

What Can You Use Instead of Cedar Mulch?

In situations where cedar mulch is not the most suitable option, there are several alternative mulching materials that gardeners can consider. Each cedar mulch alternative brings its own set of pros and cons and can be chosen based on specific garden needs, soil types, and personal preferences.

1. Wood Chip Alternatives

Wood chips are an excellent alternative to cedar mulch, especially for gardeners looking for a quicker decomposition rate and more immediate nutrient contribution to the soil. They break down faster than cedar, enriching the soil with organic matter and improving its structure. Wood chips are ideal for gardens requiring frequent soil enrichment and for gardeners who prefer to replenish their mulch layer more regularly.

2. Pine Needle Variants

For gardens with plants that thrive in acidic soil, pine needles are an outstanding mulching choice. They offer similar benefits to cedar mulch in terms of moisture retention and weed control, but they have a different impact on soil pH. Pine needles gradually acidify the soil, making them perfect for acid-loving plants like azaleas and blueberries. Their lightweight and airy structure also allow for good air circulation around plant roots.

3. Grass Clippings as an Alternative

Grass clippings are a readily available and cost-effective mulching option. As a type of organic mulch, they decompose quickly, releasing nitrogen and other nutrients back into the soil. This makes grass clippings particularly beneficial for vegetable gardens and other areas where a rapid nutrient boost is desirable. However, it’s important to use grass clippings sparingly to avoid matting and to ensure they are free of weed seeds and lawn chemicals.

closeup view of wood mulch chipsYayImages

How to Use Cedar Mulch

Using cedar mulch effectively in your garden involves a series of straightforward steps. The process ensures that your plants get the maximum benefit from the mulch without any adverse effects. Here’s a guide to help you apply cedar mulch correctly:

1. Prepare the Area

Begin by clearing the area where you plan to apply the cedar mulch. Remove any weeds, debris, or old mulch to ensure a clean surface.

2. Spread the Mulch

Evenly distribute the cedar mulch over the soil surface. Aim for a balanced layer, ideally about 2 to 3 inches thick. This thickness is sufficient to provide the benefits of mulching while allowing for proper soil aeration.

3. Avoid Plant Bases

As you spread the mulch, be careful to leave a small space around the base of each plant. This gap should be approximately 2 to 4 inches to prevent the mulch from directly touching the plant stems or tree trunks.

4. Prevent Root Smothering

Ensure that the mulch is not too thick around plant roots. A too-thick layer of mulch can smother roots, hindering their growth and access to air and water.

5. Promote Air Circulation

The space around plant bases will also promote better air circulation, reducing the risk of rot and fungal diseases that can occur in overly moist conditions.

6. Check and Maintain

Periodically check the mulch layer to maintain its optimal thickness and to ensure it hasn’t settled too close to plant bases. Replenish the mulch as needed, usually once a year, to maintain its effectiveness.

New homes backyard wood fence stone wall and landscaping garden barkdust mulchYayImages


Cedar mulch offers a myriad of benefits for gardeners seeking an organic, aesthetic, and functional mulching solution. However, understanding both its pros and cons is essential for making an informed decision on whether cedar mulch is right for your garden. Whether it’s for moisture retention, weed control, or simply for its pleasant aroma, cedar mulch can be a great addition to many gardens. Yet, for certain conditions and plant types, alternative mulching options might be more suitable. Ultimately, the use of cedar mulch should be a well-considered choice, aligning with the specific needs of your garden and plants.

Scroll to Top